Daily Quizzes in Big Classes: Half a Grade Higher, Half the Gap
Two huge psychology classes in Texas swapped exams for a short quiz at the start of every lesson. Grades rose, and the gap between social classes shrank by half.

In this post
In the autumn of 2011, two psychology lecturers at the University of Texas at Austin gave up the four big exams their introductory course had always used. In their place, every lesson began with a short quiz on laptops, marked on the spot. Nearly a thousand students took the course that way. James Pennebaker, Samuel Gosling and Jason Ferrell then compared them with the students the same two lecturers had taught three years earlier, and found more than they had set out to look for.
What the daily quiz looked like
The first ten minutes of each class went on an eight-question multiple-choice quiz. Seven questions came from the previous lecture and the readings. The eighth was personal: a question that student had answered wrongly on an earlier quiz, brought back to try again.
- 26 quizzes counted over the term, after an unmarked practice quiz on the second day.
- Each student’s three lowest scores were dropped, so one bad morning did not matter much.
- Results came back immediately, question by question, with each student’s own standing.
- The quizzes made up 86% of the grade, with four short writing assignments making up the rest. There were no exams at all.
That last point matters for anyone copying the idea. These were not low-stakes warm-ups; together they were the course grade. The authors call it frequent, consequential quizzing.
The comparison
The new class had 901 students in the final sample. The comparison group was the 935 students the same lecturers had taught in the autumn of 2008, the most recent class that had filled in the same background survey. That group had a textbook and four exams of 40 to 45 questions, which together made up the same 86% of the grade.
To compare like with like, the researchers took 17 questions that had appeared on the earlier exams and put them, unchanged, into the later quizzes.
What they found
| Measure | Exam class (2008) | Daily-quiz class (2011) |
|---|---|---|
| The 17 repeated questions | 71.2% correct | 77.1% correct |
| Grades in other courses that term | 2.96 | 3.07 |
| Grades in courses the following term | 2.98 | 3.10 |
| Grade gap, upper-middle vs lower-middle class | 0.71 of a letter grade | 0.34 of a letter grade |
On the repeated questions, the daily-quiz students scored about six points higher, which the authors describe as roughly half a letter grade. The more surprising result was outside the course. Students who had taken the quiz version did slightly better in their other classes that same term, and again in the term after, as if the habit of keeping up every day had spread.
The third result is the one that gave the paper its title. Social class was measured by the parents’ highest level of education. In the exam-based class, students from upper-middle-class homes finished 0.71 of a letter grade ahead of students from lower-middle-class homes. In the daily-quiz class, the gap was 0.34. That is a cut of a little over half, and a smaller narrowing showed up in the students’ other courses too.
Attendance was not recorded directly, but the share of students completing in-class surveys stayed far higher in the quiz class as the term went on: in November, 88.5% against 65.9%.
An older, smaller version
The idea is not new. A decade earlier, the psychology lecturer Frank Leeming tried what he called the exam-a-day procedure in four classes: a short exam at the start of every lesson instead of four large ones. Grades were significantly better than in his earlier classes on the same material, fewer students withdrew, and the daily-exam students did better on a later retention test. On anonymous questionnaires, most said the routine made them study more and learn more than in their other courses, and that they liked it.
The limits
Neither study is a controlled experiment. Pennebaker and his colleagues are frank that theirs is a case study of two semesters, and that more than the quizzes changed: the textbook was replaced by online readings, and some lessons included short online discussions. They write that it is not possible to tell which features caused the changes. The benchmark difference on the 17 questions was also only marginally significant, and the earlier class had its exam grades curved, which complicates the raw grade comparison.
What the findings do support is the direction. A course built around a short quiz every lesson produced at least as much learning as one built around big exams, attendance held up, and the students who usually fall behind fell less far behind.
Borrowing the routine
Few teachers want to make quizzes 86% of a grade, and there is no need to. The parts of the design that look most useful travel well on their own.
A start-of-lesson quiz, Texas style
- Open every lesson with the same short quiz, around eight questions, so it becomes a habit rather than an event.
- Ask mostly about the last lesson, and add one question the class got wrong before.
- Show the results straight away, then spend two minutes on the question most people missed.
- Drop a few of the lowest scores, if you record them at all, so an off day does not count.
The returning question is the cleverest piece. It costs nothing to add, it tells students that a wrong answer is something to come back to rather than something to forget, and it builds a little spacing into every lesson without any extra planning. For more on why recalling beats rereading, see practice tests versus re-reading.
Sources
- Pennebaker, J. W., Gosling, S. D. & Ferrell, J. D. (2013). Daily online testing in large classes: Boosting college performance while reducing achievement gaps. PLoS ONE, 8(11), e79774.
- Leeming, F. C. (2002). The exam-a-day procedure improves performance in psychology classes. Teaching of Psychology, 29(3), 210–212.
Try it in Giga Quizzes
Free, in the browser, and nothing for your students to install. These guides show each step on the real screens.
New to Giga Quizzes?
Free live quizzes in the browser. Students join from any phone, with no app.
Make your first quiz →

