What the research says

What 93 Studies Say About Game-Based Quizzes in Class

A review of 93 studies of live game-based quizzes looked at grades, classroom atmosphere, anxiety and what students found hard. The findings, the caveats, and what to do with them.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
A game controller lit by glowing purple neon
Photo: Sreenand, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1How the review was done
  2. 2Learning: mostly positive, with exceptions
  3. 3Atmosphere and anxiety
  4. 4What students and teachers found hard
  5. 5What students say in their own words
  6. 6Reading the review with care

Live quiz games, where a question goes up on the big screen and the whole class races to answer on their phones, spread through classrooms in the 2010s. Researchers followed, and by 2019 there were enough studies of one platform, Kahoot!, for a proper review. Alf Inge Wang and Rabail Tahir collected and read them. Their review is the largest single look at how game-based quizzes affect real classes, and it is useful well beyond any one product, because most live quiz games work the same basic way.

How the review was done

The authors searched Google Scholar and four research databases and found 206 articles that qualified for a closer look. They then read each one and rejected those that did not describe their method, did not present results, drew conclusions without data, or used the quiz alongside other tools without separating its effect. That left 93 studies.

They organised the evidence around five questions: does it affect learning, does it change the atmosphere in the room, does it affect anxiety, and what do students and teachers think of it. The last of these was by far the most studied. Eighty-two of the 93 studies included results on how students perceived the experience; anxiety and teachers’ views had the fewest.

Learning: mostly positive, with exceptions

Forty-eight studies measured learning outcomes. Most compared classes that used the quiz game with traditional teaching, and 70% of the studies that ran significance tests found that the game improved grades or test results compared with the other approach.

Some of the individual studies are telling. In one Spanish chemistry course with 89 students, two groups used the game, one twice as often as the other, and both improved on traditional teaching, with the more frequent group improving most. But not every comparison favoured the game. In an information technology course, a game-based quiz did not produce better learning than the same quiz on paper or with simple clickers.

That pattern is worth taking seriously. Against a lecture with no questions at all, a live quiz usually wins. Against another form of active questioning, the advantage is smaller or disappears. Much of the benefit seems to come from the questioning itself, which fits what the wider research on practice tests would predict.

Atmosphere and anxiety

Studies of classroom dynamics, the energy, interaction and willingness to take part in the room, generally found a positive effect, though few of them used statistics, so the authors call for more experiments before drawing a firm conclusion.

Anxiety is the question many teachers ask first, since a game built on points, timers and a scoreboard sounds stressful. Fourteen studies touched on it. Ten reported that the quiz game reduced anxiety: about asking questions, about being judged, or about joining in at all. In one example, 56% of students taught traditionally said they were afraid to ask questions in class, against 37% of those who played quizzes. Only two of the fourteen tested the difference statistically, and both found lower anxiety. One study reported the opposite problem: the most common complaint was agitation in the class.

The review also notes one reason quiz games may feel safer than a raised hand: students play under nicknames, so a wrong answer is not public in the way a spoken one is.

What students and teachers found hard

The most practical section of the review lists the difficulties people reported. They read like a checklist for running a better quiz.

Difficulty reportedWhat helps
Not enough time, or stressful time pressureGive harder questions longer timers; keep speed bonuses for quick recall
Hard to read questions on a projected screenShort questions, big text, and answers repeated on students’ own devices
Afraid of losing; hard to catch up after a wrong answerTeam play, several short games instead of one long one, and modes where the lead changes
Fast scoring encourages guessing without thinkingLower the points on reflective questions, or pause for discussion before the reveal
Getting the difficulty rightAim for questions that split the class, then check the results to adjust
Unreliable connectionsTest the network before an important lesson
Difficulties from Wang & Tahir (2020); suggestions are ours

What students say in their own words

Numbers only go so far, so it is worth hearing students directly. Sherlock Licorish and colleagues interviewed 14 of the 48 students in an information systems course at a New Zealand university after a semester in which quizzes were used in seven lectures. The students said the biggest effects were on classroom dynamics, engagement and motivation, and the authors concluded that games in class are likely to cut down on distractions. They also named what made the difference: questions well matched to the lecture, feedback straight away, and the game elements themselves.

Reading the review with care

A few cautions. Many of the 93 studies measured what students thought of the quiz rather than what they learned, and self-reports tend to be kind to anything fun. Only some of the studies of learning, atmosphere and anxiety used statistical tests. Most compare a game with traditional teaching, which sets a low bar. And readers should know that Wang’s own research project in the 2000s led to the platform the review studies, though the authors set out their selection rules and reasons for rejecting studies in full.

Taken together, the evidence supports a measured conclusion rather than a sales pitch: live quiz games tend to make classes livelier, can lower the fear of taking part, and usually help learning compared with teaching that asks students nothing. How much they help depends on the questions and on what the teacher does with the answers.

Sources

  1. Wang, A. I. & Tahir, R. (2020). The effect of using Kahoot! for learning – A literature review. Computers & Education, 149, 103818.
  2. Licorish, S. A., Owen, H. E., Daniel, B. & George, J. L. (2018). Students’ perception of Kahoot!’s influence on teaching and learning. Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Learning, 13, article 9.

More from the blog

All posts →