Is Competition Good for Learning?
Competition helps some students and hurts others, and a large meta-analysis explains why. What three studies found, and how to keep a class quiz on the helpful side.

In this post
Every teacher who runs a quiz with a scoreboard has watched both versions of competition. One student sits up straighter, desperate to win the next round. Another goes quiet after a slow start and stops trying. Both reactions are real, and research has a neat explanation for why the same scoreboard pushes students in opposite directions. This post covers a large review of competition and performance, a classroom-style experiment with a live scoreboard, and a set of studies on teams, then turns them into practical choices.
The big picture: no simple answer
Kou Murayama and Andrew Elliot set out to answer the broad question directly: across all the studies that exist, how is competition related to performance? They ran a meta-analysis, and the answer surprised many readers. Overall, there was no noteworthy relation between competition and performance at all.
That does not mean competition does nothing. It means it does two opposite things at once, and on average they cancel out. Murayama and Elliot called their explanation the opposing processes model, and they tested it with a second meta-analysis and three new studies of their own.
Two goals, pulling in opposite directions
The model rests on a distinction between two kinds of goal that competition tends to switch on.
| Goal | What the student is thinking | Effect on performance |
|---|---|---|
| Performance-approach | “I want to do better than the others.” | Helps |
| Performance-avoidance | “I don’t want to do worse than the others.” | Hurts |
Competition raises both kinds of goal. Students who mostly feel the first pull put in more effort. Students who mostly feel the second worry about losing, and that worry undermines what they do. Across the three new studies, which defined competition in three different ways and controlled for many other factors, the same pattern held.
For a teacher, this is the key idea. The question is not whether to use competition, but how to set it up so that students feel the pull to do well more than the fear of doing badly.
A live scoreboard, tested
A study by Nergiz Ercil Cagiltay, Erol Ozcelik and Nese Sahin Ozcelik looks a lot like a classroom quiz. They built a game that taught database modelling and made two versions. In the competitive version, every player could see all the current players’ scores, rankings and nicknames, updating in real time. In the other version there was no scoreboard. The 142 undergraduates who took part were assigned at random to one version or the other, and all of them were new to the topic.
| Measure | With the scoreboard | Without it |
|---|---|---|
| Motivation (questionnaire score) | 136.3 | 129.8 |
| Score on a test afterwards | 24.5 | 20.9 |
The competitive group was more motivated and did better on the test that followed. They also spent more of their time answering the game’s questions, and time spent answering went with better scores. Competition, in this setting, seems to have helped by making students take the questions more seriously.
The study has limits worth stating: one session, one topic, university students, and players who were not allowed to work together. But it is good evidence that a scoreboard is not automatically harmful, and can help.
Teams change the equation
John Tauer and Judith Harackiewicz compared competition, cooperation and a mix of the two in four studies, three of them built around shooting baskets. Pure competition and pure cooperation came out about the same for enjoyment and performance. The mix, cooperating within a team while competing against another team, consistently produced the highest intrinsic motivation, and in two of the three behavioural studies, the best performance too.
This lines up with a pattern seen elsewhere in this series: the gamification meta-analysis also found that competition combined with collaboration worked better than competition alone. A plausible reason, in the language of the opposing processes model, is that a team spreads the risk. Losing as a team stings less than losing alone, so the fear of doing badly has less to grip on, while the wish to win stays.
Keeping a class quiz on the helpful side
None of these studies tested the following suggestions directly; they are ways of applying the opposing processes model to an ordinary lesson.
- Lower the stakes. Scores that do not count towards grades leave room to try and fail.
- Use teams regularly. Team against team keeps the energy of competition and softens the sting of losing.
- Give many chances to win. Short games, several rounds and modes where the lead changes hands mean a slow start is not the end of the story.
- Celebrate the top, not the bottom. Showing the leaders gives everyone a target; publicly ranking the last few mostly feeds the fear of doing worse.
- Praise improvement. “Who beat their score from last week?” is a competition every student can enter.
- Keep the content the point. Pause after questions the class found hard, so the game serves the learning rather than the other way round.
Watch your own class, too. If the same few students win every time and the rest have stopped trying, the avoidance pull is winning. Mixing up the format for a few weeks, with teams or a solo game against their own previous score, often brings the quiet ones back.
Sources
- Murayama, K. & Elliot, A. J. (2012). The competition–performance relation: A meta-analytic review and test of the opposing processes model of competition and performance. Psychological Bulletin, 138(6), 1035–1070.
- Cagiltay, N. E., Ozcelik, E. & Ozcelik, N. S. (2015). The effect of competition on learning in games. Computers & Education, 87, 35–41.
- Tauer, J. M. & Harackiewicz, J. M. (2004). The effects of cooperation and competition on intrinsic motivation and performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 86(6), 849–861.
Try it in Giga Quizzes
Free, in the browser, and nothing for your students to install. These guides show each step on the real screens.
New to Giga Quizzes?
Free live quizzes in the browser. Students join from any phone, with no app.
Make your first quiz →

