What the research says

Learning by Getting Ready to Teach

Students told they would teach a passage remembered more of it than students expecting a test, though nobody taught. Another study found children try harder for a pupil.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
A green apple resting on a small stack of books
Photo: White Wings, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1Expecting to teach
  2. 2The protégé effect
  3. 3Why it might work
  4. 4The limits
  5. 5Putting the teacher role to work

Teachers often say they never really understood a topic until they had to teach it. Part of that is the teaching itself: explaining, answering questions, noticing gaps. But part of it may come earlier, in the preparation. Two lines of research suggest that simply expecting to teach changes how people learn, and that having someone to teach, even a computer character, makes children try harder.

Expecting to teach

John Nestojko, Dung Bui, Nate Kornell and Elizabeth Bjork ran a series of reading-and-recall experiments with one small manipulation. Before reading a passage, half the participants were told they would be tested on it. The other half were told they would teach it to another student.

In fact nobody taught anyone. Everyone took the same test. The only difference between the two groups was what they expected while they were reading.

That expectation was enough. Participants who expected to teach recalled more of the passage, organised what they recalled more effectively, and remembered the most important information especially well. On questions about the passage, they generally answered more correctly, particularly questions about the main points.

Nestojko suggested why. When teachers prepare to teach, he said, they tend to seek out key points and organise information into a coherent structure. Expecting to teach seems to switch on those same habits in a learner. The striking part, in his words, is that learning was significantly affected even though the researchers did nothing more than alter participants’ expectations.

The protégé effect

Catherine Chase, Doris Chin, Marily Oppezzo and Daniel Schwartz at Stanford studied a related idea with children. They used a learning program called Betty’s Brain, in which students teach a computer character, called a teachable agent, by showing it how the ideas in a topic connect. The agent then reasons using what it has been taught, and can answer questions right or wrong depending on how well it was taught.

In the first study, eighth graders learned biology either by teaching their agent or by learning the same material for themselves. Students in the teaching condition spent more time on learning activities and learned more, and the benefit was especially large for lower-achieving students. The authors named this the protégé effect: students made greater effort to learn for their agents than they did for themselves.

The second study, with fifth graders, looked at why. The children treated their agents as social beings: they spoke of them as having thoughts and shared responsibility with them for right and wrong answers. They were also more willing to acknowledge mistakes. When the agent got something wrong, it was partly the agent’s mistake, which made it easier to look at and fix.

Why it might work

The two studies point to different mechanisms, and both are plausible together.

  • A different way of reading. Preparing to teach means asking what matters most and how the parts fit together, which is good study practice.
  • Responsibility. Having someone depend on you is motivating, even when that someone is a character on a screen.
  • A buffer for failure. A mistake made while teaching feels less personal than a mistake on a test, so it is easier to face and correct.

The limits

The expecting-to-teach experiments measured memory soon after reading, with text passages, and the published reports give the results as group differences rather than as a classroom outcome. The teachable-agent studies used one particular program, and part of its benefit may come from the program itself, not only from the role of teacher. Neither shows that every student learns better as a teacher, and actual teaching takes time that has to come from somewhere.

Putting the teacher role to work

The cheapest version of this is the one in the first study: tell students they will explain the material to someone else, and let that expectation shape how they prepare.

Ways to make students the teacher

  • Before a reading, tell students they will explain the main points to a partner afterwards.
  • Ask small groups to write a few quiz questions on a topic for another group to answer.
  • Have students host a short review quiz for the class, explaining each answer in the reveal.
  • Pair older students with younger ones for practice, with the older ones preparing the questions.
  • When an answer is wrong, ask the class how they would explain it to someone who got it wrong.

The expectation has to be believable, though. A class that is told every week that it will explain something, and then never does, will soon stop preparing as if it might. Following through, even briefly, keeps the expectation real.

Writing questions is a particularly good fit. To write a fair question and three plausible wrong answers, a student has to know what matters, what is commonly confused and why the right answer is right. For help with that, see turning a lesson into quiz questions, and for a related approach where students explain to each other mid-lesson, Peer Instruction.

Sources

  1. Nestojko, J. F., Bui, D. C., Kornell, N. & Bjork, E. L. (2014). Expecting to teach enhances learning and organization of knowledge in free recall of text passages. Memory & Cognition, 42(7), 1038–1048.
  2. Chase, C. C., Chin, D. B., Oppezzo, M. & Schwartz, D. L. (2009). Teachable agents and the protégé effect: Increasing the effort towards learning. Journal of Science Education and Technology, 18(4), 334–352.
  3. Washington University in St. Louis (2014). Expecting to teach enhances learning, recall. The Source (news release).

More from the blog

All posts →