What the research says

Does Music in a Classroom Quiz Matter?

One lecture, taught four times to 593 students, with the quiz’s music and points switched on and off. What changed in the room, what students reported, and what it did not show.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
A pair of headphones on a soft pink and orange background
Photo: Ervo Rocks, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1A neat experiment
  2. 2What changed when both were switched off
  3. 3The surprise: music changed the room
  4. 4What the study did not show
  5. 5What to do with it

Most live quiz games come with music: a countdown track while students answer, a sound when the answers are revealed. It is easy to assume the music is decoration and turn it off when the room feels too loud. A field experiment at a Norwegian university tested what actually happens to a class when the sound goes, and when the points go too. The answer is more interesting than “students like music”.

A neat experiment

Alf Inge Wang and Andreas Lieberoth had an unusual opportunity. A large introductory IT course at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology was so big that the same lecture had to be given four times, by the same lecturer, to four different groups of first-year students. That made it possible to change one thing at a time and compare.

The lecture, on software engineering, was taught through a 22-question quiz instead of slides: a question, the students’ answers, then the lecturer’s comments on how they had answered before explaining further. The four groups played the quiz in four ways.

GroupMusic and soundPoints
Full gameOnOn
No audioOffOn
No pointsOnOff
NeitherOffOff
The four versions of the same lecture, Wang & Lieberoth (2016)

Afterwards 593 students filled in a questionnaire about concentration, engagement, enjoyment, learning and motivation, and the researchers observed each lecture.

What changed when both were switched off

The clearest effects appeared in the group that had neither music nor points.

Students who agreed that…Full gameNeither
The quiz kept my concentration during the lecture82%72%
Playing the quiz was fun92%75%
Selected results, Wang & Lieberoth (2016); the differences across the four groups were statistically significant

Concentration during the lecture was significantly lower without both elements, though concentration while playing the quiz itself did not differ. The quiz was rated fun by 91% to 94% of students in the three groups with at least one element, and by 75% in the group with neither.

Points had their own effect. When points were on, 68% to 69% of students said they felt their pulse rise when answering; with points off it was 32% to 39%. Points, in other words, are where the tension comes from.

The surprise: music changed the room

The most striking result did not come from the questionnaires at all. The researchers watched each lecture, and the four rooms felt completely different.

  • Full game: high spirits, laughter, focused students, loud discussion between questions, cheering at correct answers, open questions to the lecturer. The class was highly responsive.
  • No audio: a quiet room of concentrated students, with no cheering, no discussion and no questions during the lecture.
  • No points: high spirits and laughter, quieter cheering, some discussion, and open questions during the lecture.
  • Neither: low energy, a totally quiet room, no celebration and little response.

The authors’ conclusion was that audio had the largest effect on classroom dynamics. The sound simply produced more energy in the room and opened it up for interaction. The best atmosphere came from music and points together.

One more detail is worth knowing. Students in the group with points but no music tried hardest: only 7% of them said they did not try very hard, against 23% to 36% in the other groups. Based on students’ comments, the researchers suggest that without the music, the quiz felt more like a formal test.

What the study did not show

It is tempting to read this as “music makes students learn more”. The study does not show that. Learning was measured only by asking students whether they felt they had learned something, and 90% or more in every group said yes, with no significant difference between groups. There was no test of what they actually remembered.

There are other limits too. The questionnaire used single statements with four-point agree-or-disagree answers, the classroom observations were the researchers’ own impressions rather than a coded measure, and all four groups came from one course, one lecturer and one topic at one university. The authors themselves describe the paper as a first, broad analysis.

What to do with it

The study gives teachers a way to think about sound as a dial rather than a switch, depending on what the lesson needs.

Choosing the sound for the moment

  • Want energy, talk and questions? Keep the music and the points on. That combination produced the liveliest, most responsive rooms.
  • Want quiet focus, close to exam conditions? Turn the music off and keep the points. Students in that group concentrated and tried hard, though the room was silent.
  • Worried about pressure? Points, not music, are what raise the pulse. Lowering or removing points takes the edge off while the music keeps the atmosphere friendly.
  • Avoid switching both off unless you have a reason. That version was the least fun and the least engaging.

Whatever you choose, it helps to tell the class why. “No music today, this one is practice for the exam” sets a different mood from a celebratory end-of-term game, and students take the cue.

Sources

  1. Wang, A. I. & Lieberoth, A. (2016). The effect of points and audio on concentration, engagement, enjoyment, learning, motivation, and classroom dynamics using Kahoot!. Proceedings of the 10th European Conference on Games Based Learning (ECGBL 2016), p. 738.

More from the blog

All posts →