Quizzing Protects Memory Under Stress
Stress makes memories harder to reach. A study in Science found that material learned with practice tests stayed reachable under stress, while material learned by restudying did not.

In this post
Every teacher has seen it: a student who clearly knew the material the day before goes blank in the exam. Research on stress and memory explains part of it. Acute stress, especially about twenty minutes after it starts, makes stored memories harder to retrieve. In 2016 Amy Smith, Victoria Floerke and Ayanna Thomas at Tufts University asked a hopeful question. Is every memory equally fragile, or are some memories strong enough that stress cannot knock them out?
The experiment
One hundred and twenty participants, with an average age of 20, learned 30 concrete nouns as words and 30 more as pictures, one at a time. Half of each set had a negative tone and half were neutral. Then they practised in one of two ways.
- Study practice: they looked at all the items again, several times. In total they studied the material four times.
- Retrieval practice: after the first viewing, they wrote down as many items as they could remember, three times over, without being told what they had missed.
The next day, half of each group went through a well-known laboratory stress procedure: giving an unprepared speech and doing mental arithmetic in front of two judges and three peers. Pulse readings confirmed that it worked. The other half did a calm task of the same length. Everyone then took two memory tests: one about five minutes after the stress began, and one about twenty minutes after that, when the stress hormone cortisol is near its peak.
What they found
On the later test, the one that usually shows the damage, the study-practice group behaved exactly as earlier research predicts. Stressed participants recalled noticeably fewer items than calm ones.
The retrieval-practice group did not. Stressed participants recalled about as much as calm ones, as though the stress had not happened. Stressed participants who had learned by retrieval even outperformed calm participants who had learned by restudying.
| Average items recalled | Five minutes after stress began | Twenty-five minutes after |
|---|---|---|
| Learned by restudying | 8.2 | 7.9 |
| Learned by retrieval practice | 9.9 | 10.7 |
In effect-size terms, stress cost the restudy group about 0.44 of a standard deviation on the later test. Retrieval practice did more than cancel that loss. Stressed participants who had learned by retrieval beat stressed participants who had restudied by more than a full standard deviation (d = 1.16), and calm retrieval learners beat them by almost as much (d = 0.97).
The early test told a different story: five minutes in, stress neither hurt nor helped anyone. That fits what is known about the body’s stress response, which comes in two waves. Adrenaline arrives first and may even sharpen processing; cortisol builds more slowly, and it is cortisol that interferes with the parts of the brain that retrieve memories.
Why practised recall might resist stress
The authors offer an explanation based on how retrieval practice works. Each time you pull something out of memory, you strengthen not only the memory itself but the routes to it, the cues and contexts that lead back to it. A memory reached several times by different routes has more than one way in. If stress blocks one route, another may still be open. Restudying, which mostly means recognising something you are looking at, builds fewer of those routes.
It is worth noticing how little the retrieval group actually did differently. Both groups met the same words and pictures on the first day. One group looked at them again; the other tried to write them down from memory. The second activity feels harder and less productive while you are doing it, because you can see how much you have forgotten. That feeling is misleading, and this study adds one more cost to trusting it.
They also point to the obvious application. Students with test anxiety often know the material but cannot reach it under pressure. If the material was learned by recalling it, the pressure may matter less.
The limits
This was one experiment, with word and picture lists rather than school subjects, and with a laboratory stress procedure rather than a real exam. The final tests came a day after learning, not weeks later. The retrieval group also practised without feedback, which is not how most classroom quizzes work. The result is striking and fits a large body of research on retrieval practice, but it should be read as a promising finding, not a cure for exam nerves.
What it suggests for exam preparation
The practical advice is the same as for remembering anything, with one extra reason behind it. Material that students have recalled many times is not only remembered better on a good day; it may also hold up on a bad one.
Revision that holds up under pressure
- Replace a final read-through with a final practice quiz.
- Recall each topic more than once, spread over the days before the exam.
- Use questions that make students produce or choose an answer, not just recognise a summary.
- Keep practice quizzes low-stakes, so the practice itself is not another source of stress.
There is a further benefit that this study did not measure but others have: students who are used to being quizzed tend to find tests less frightening. The post on quizzes and test anxiety looks at that research.
Sources
- Smith, A. M., Floerke, V. A. & Thomas, A. K. (2016). Retrieval practice protects memory against acute stress. Science, 354(6315), 1046–1048.
Try it in Giga Quizzes
Free, in the browser, and nothing for your students to install. These guides show each step on the real screens.
New to Giga Quizzes?
Free live quizzes in the browser. Students join from any phone, with no app.
Make your first quiz →

