What the research says

Spacing: Three Short Sessions Beat One Long One

The same practice, spread over several days instead of done in one sitting, is remembered far better. A review of 317 experiments and a classroom study with 213 pupils show how much.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
Illustrated calendar pages for different months pinned side by side
Photo: Jason Leung, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1Three hundred experiments
  2. 2Spacing in a real school
  3. 3Why spacing works
  4. 4The limits
  5. 5Spacing a topic across lessons

If you have an hour to practise something, does it matter whether you spend it in one go or in three twenty-minute sessions on different days? It feels as if it should not. The total effort is the same. But more than a century of research on what is called the spacing effect says it matters a great deal, and two studies show how robust the finding is: one that pooled hundreds of experiments, and one that tested the idea with real school maths.

Three hundred experiments

In 2006 Nicholas Cepeda, Harold Pashler, Edward Vul, John Wixted and Doug Rohrer gathered the research on spacing in verbal learning: memorising words, facts and similar material. They found 839 comparisons in 317 experiments from 184 articles.

Across every retention interval in the data, material studied in spaced sessions was recalled at 47.3% on the final test, against 36.7% for the same material studied in a single block. Spacing won by more than ten points on average, with the same total study time.

The review then asked a harder question: how big should the gap be? The answer turned out to depend on how long the material needs to last. The gap that produced the best memory grew as the time until the final test grew. A short gap suits a test that comes soon; a test months away is best served by gaps of days or weeks. For most of what school is for, the authors note, that means gaps well beyond a day.

The authors put the educational message bluntly: separating learning sessions by at least a day, rather than concentrating them into one session, is extremely useful for long-term retention. Every study they found that measured memory more than a month later showed a benefit from spreading learning over weeks or months, with an average benefit of 15 percent, and the benefit appeared in children as well as adults.

Spacing in a real school

Laboratory word lists are one thing; school maths is another. Katharina Barzagar Nazari and Mirjam Ebersbach tested spacing with 213 pupils in third and seventh grade, using a maths topic taken from each class’s own curriculum.

All pupils were first introduced to the topic. Then they practised it with three sets of problems, in one of two ways.

GroupPractice schedule
MassedAll three practice sets on the same day
SpacedOne practice set a day, on three days in a row
Barzagar Nazari & Ebersbach (2019)

The amount of practice was identical; only the timing differed. Pupils were then tested one week and six weeks after their last practice set.

In seventh grade, spaced practice beat massed practice on both tests, after one week and after six. In third grade, the benefit was clear at one week but not supported by the data at six weeks. The authors conclude that distributed practice is a powerful learning tool in the classroom, for both primary and secondary pupils.

Why spacing works

There is no single agreed explanation, but the leading ideas fit everyday experience. Practice that comes straight after the last attempt is easy, because the material is still fresh, and easy practice does little to strengthen memory. After a gap, some of it has slipped, and bringing it back takes effort. That effort, the work of retrieving something partly forgotten, is what makes the memory more durable. Spaced sessions also happen in different moods and settings, which may give the memory more cues to be found by later.

Spacing also has an unhelpful feature: it feels worse. Massed practice gives a smooth sense of getting better within a session. Spaced practice starts each session with a little forgetting, which can feel like failure. Students left to choose often prefer massed practice for exactly that reason.

The limits

Most of the studies in the review used verbal material such as word lists and facts, and the authors stress that the best gap for long-term learning is still not known precisely, because long studies are slow and expensive to run. The school study tested one topic per grade and one schedule of three days. Neither study says exactly how far apart sessions should be for a skill a student needs next year. They agree on the direction: spread it out.

Spacing a topic across lessons

For teachers, spacing is less about new activities than about rearranging the ones already planned. A quiz is an ideal tool, because it is short and can return to any topic at any time.

A simple spacing plan

  • Instead of one long practice session at the end of a topic, split it into three short ones on different days.
  • Start lessons with a few questions on last week’s topic, not just yesterday’s.
  • Before a test, revisit each topic briefly over several days rather than all at once the night before.
  • Expect the first questions after a gap to go worse. That is the forgetting that makes the practice work.

Spacing combines well with mixing topics together, which has its own research: see mixing topics in practice. And the first part of the spacing story, how fast memories fade without it, is the subject of the forgetting curve, re-run.

Sources

  1. Cepeda, N. J., Pashler, H., Vul, E., Wixted, J. T. & Rohrer, D. (2006). Distributed practice in verbal recall tasks: A review and quantitative synthesis. Psychological Bulletin, 132(3), 354–380.
  2. Barzagar Nazari, K. & Ebersbach, M. (2019). Distributing mathematical practice of third and seventh graders: Applicability of the spacing effect in the classroom. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 33(2), 288–298.

More from the blog

All posts →