Two-Stage Exams: Test Alone, Then Together
Students sit a test alone, then answer the same questions again in small groups. A controlled study at the University of British Columbia measured what students remembered three days later.

In this post
Most tests end the moment the papers are collected, and the learning that could happen in the next ten minutes, when students are bursting to know whether they got it right, is lost. A two-stage exam keeps that moment. Students take the test on their own, hand it in, and then take it again straight away in small groups, arguing their way to shared answers. Science departments at the University of British Columbia have taken up the format, and one study there tested whether the group stage really helps students remember more.
How a two-stage exam works
- Stage one: each student writes the exam alone, as normal, and hands it in.
- Stage two: students form groups of three to five and immediately answer the same or very similar questions together, handing in one paper per group.
- Marking: the individual paper is still marked, so each student’s own work is assessed. How much the group paper adds varies from course to course.
The second stage is usually much quicker than the first. Carl Wieman, Georg Rieger and Cynthia Heiner, describing the format in UBC’s physics department, write that during the group stage the room fills with spirited and effective debate, with nearly every student participating. Students get immediate, targeted feedback from each other on exactly the questions they have just struggled with, and the exam still measures what each of them can do alone.
The study
The obvious objection is that students in a two-stage exam simply see the questions twice. Any improvement might come from the extra time on the questions, not from working together. Brett Gilley and Bridgette Clarkston designed a study to separate the two.
It ran in a three-week summer course on natural disasters, taken mostly by students who were not majoring in science, with 98 students. Each of two midterms, held on a Friday, was a two-stage exam with a twist. Ten of the questions were split into two topics. In the group stage, each group re-answered the questions from one topic only. For the other topic, students re-did the questions on their own instead, so that they spent the same extra time on them but without a group. On the following Monday, three days later, everyone took a short individual retention test on all ten questions.
Because each student met one topic in a group and the other alone, every student acted as their own comparison.
What they found
| First midterm | Score in the exam | Score three days later | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Questions re-done alone | 64.8% | 68.6% | +3.8 (not significant) |
| Questions re-done in a group | 64.6% | 77.7% | +13.1 |
Questions that students had worked through in a group were remembered much better three days later than questions they had re-done alone, even though the time spent was matched. On the second midterm the pattern repeated: a gain of about 13 points for group questions against about 4 for questions re-done alone.
Two further findings matter for teachers. The benefit was similar for students in the lower, middle and upper thirds of the class, so it was not just the weaker students catching up or the stronger ones pulling ahead. And individual results on the retention test appeared to be influenced by how well the student’s group had done in the second stage: a group that reasoned its way to the right answer carried its members with it.
The limits
Three days is a short time; the study cannot say how long the advantage lasts. It was one course, taught in an intensive summer format, at one university, and the full article sits in a teaching journal, with the numbers above taken from the authors’ own summary of the results. The group stage also only helps as much as the group discussion does: a group that agrees on a wrong answer will reinforce it, which is consistent with the finding that group performance shaped individual results.
Two stages in an ordinary lesson
You do not need a formal exam to borrow the idea. The core of it is simple: commit alone, then argue it out, then check. That is the same structure that makes Peer Instruction work, applied to a whole set of questions instead of one.
A two-stage review quiz
- Run a short review quiz with everyone answering alone. Do not reveal the answers yet.
- Put students into groups of three or four and give them the same questions on paper or on screen.
- Each group agrees on one answer per question, and must be able to explain it.
- Reveal the answers and go through the ones where groups disagreed.
- A few days later, ask a few of the same questions again, individually, to see what stuck.
Playing the same quiz first solo and then in teams is a quick version of this. The solo round shows what each student knows; the team round gives them a reason to talk it through. The difference between a student’s two results is a small, visible measure of what the conversation added.
Keep the stakes of the solo round low, and make the group stage feel like a puzzle rather than a second exam. The point is the discussion, and students discuss most honestly when the right answer is something they want to find, not something they are being graded on.
Sources
- Gilley, B. H. & Clarkston, B. (2014). Collaborative testing: Evidence of learning in a controlled in-class study of undergraduate students. Journal of College Science Teaching, 43(3), 83–91.
- Gilley, B. & Clarkston, B. (2013). Does collaborative testing increase students’ retention of concepts? (results summary). Carl Wieman Science Education Initiative, University of British Columbia.
- Wieman, C. E., Rieger, G. W. & Heiner, C. E. (2014). Physics exams that promote collaborative learning. The Physics Teacher, 52(1), 51–53.
Try it in Giga Quizzes
Free, in the browser, and nothing for your students to install. These guides show each step on the real screens.
New to Giga Quizzes?
Free live quizzes in the browser. Students join from any phone, with no app.
Make your first quiz →

