What the research says

Why Re-Reading Feels Like Learning

Most students revise by re-reading, though testing themselves works better. A survey of 177 students and a review of learning versus performance explain why the wrong method feels right.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
An open book on a glossy surface under orange and blue light
Photo: Chase Kennedy, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1What students actually do
  2. 2Learning is not performance
  3. 3Re-reading through this lens
  4. 4The limits
  5. 5Helping students choose better

Research on study methods has a frustrating result at its centre. Testing yourself, by trying to recall what you have learned, produces much more lasting memory than reading the same material again. This has been shown so often that it is one of the safest findings in educational psychology. And yet when students study on their own, most of them re-read. Two papers explain the gap: a survey of what students actually do, and a review of why the mind misjudges its own learning.

What students actually do

Jeffrey Karpicke, Andrew Butler and Henry Roediger surveyed 177 university students about how they study. They asked in two ways.

  1. An open question: list the strategies you use when studying.
  2. A forced choice: after reading a textbook chapter once, would you rather read it again, or try to recall what it said?

Both questions pointed to the same conclusion. A majority of students repeatedly read their notes or textbook, even though re-reading often adds little beyond the first reading. Relatively few practised retrieval or tested themselves while studying.

The authors propose that students experience illusions of competence while studying. Reading a page for the second time feels easy and familiar, and that ease is taken as a sign of knowing. The trouble is that recognising something on the page is not the same as being able to produce it when the page is gone, which is what an exam asks.

Learning is not performance

Nicholas Soderstrom and Robert Bjork set this in a broader frame. They distinguish two things that are easy to confuse.

PerformanceLearning
What it isHow well you do during practiceLasting change in knowledge and skill
When you can see itRight nowLater: days, weeks, months
What it feels likeVisible and reassuringInvisible while it happens
The distinction reviewed by Soderstrom & Bjork (2015)

The goal of teaching is learning: relatively permanent change that supports retention and transfer. But during teaching, the only thing anyone can see is performance. And performance during practice, the review argues, is often an unreliable guide to learning.

The review brings together evidence that the two can come apart in both directions. Learning can happen without any visible change in performance at the time. More troublingly, practice can produce fast gains in performance that leave little lasting learning behind, and some ways of practising have opposite effects on the two: they make practice look worse but leave more learning, or make practice look better and leave less.

The final piece is metacognition, people’s judgements of their own learning. The review describes research showing that people often take their performance during practice as a reliable sign of how much they have learned. Since performance and learning can diverge, this leads them, quite reasonably from their point of view, to prefer the methods that feel productive over the ones that are.

Re-reading through this lens

Re-reading is a textbook case. During a second reading, everything feels familiar and the pages go by smoothly, so performance in the moment seems high. Self-testing exposes gaps: you cannot remember, you get things wrong, it feels like failing. By the feeling of practice, re-reading wins. By what is remembered a week later, self-testing wins.

None of this makes students foolish. They are judging by the evidence in front of them, and the evidence in front of them is misleading.

The same pattern appears with other methods. Mixing topics feels harder than practising one at a time, and spacing sessions out feels worse than cramming, yet both leave more learning. In the paintings study, most participants still preferred the method that had worked worse for them, even after taking the test.

The limits

The survey asked students to describe their habits, which is not the same as watching them study, and it was one group of university students. The review is a synthesis of other research rather than a new experiment. Neither paper says re-reading is useless; a first careful reading is necessary, and re-reading has some value. The point is that it feels far more effective than it is.

Helping students choose better

Telling students that self-testing works is rarely enough, because their own experience keeps telling them otherwise. It helps to change the experience.

Making good study feel worth it

  • Build recall into lessons, so students practise retrieval without having to choose it.
  • Show the evidence in their own results: a quick quiz on material they re-read against material they recalled.
  • Explain that difficulty during practice is often a sign of learning, not failure.
  • Give students ready-made practice quizzes for revision, so testing is as easy to start as reading.
  • After a test, ask how they studied, and connect the answer to their score.

The evidence for testing over re-reading is explained in practice tests versus re-reading. This post is about the other half of the problem: why, knowing all that, so many of us still reach for the highlighter.

Sources

  1. Karpicke, J. D., Butler, A. C. & Roediger, H. L. (2009). Metacognitive strategies in student learning: Do students practise retrieval when they study on their own?. Memory, 17(4), 471–479.
  2. Soderstrom, N. C. & Bjork, R. A. (2015). Learning versus performance: An integrative review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 10(2), 176–199.

More from the blog

All posts →