What the research says

Does Cold-Calling Make Students Speak Up More?

Many teachers avoid calling on students who have not raised a hand, fearing it makes them uncomfortable. A study of university classes found more volunteers, and more comfort.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
A hand reaching upwards against a deep teal background
Photo: Sindy Süßengut, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1Why it is worth asking
  2. 2The study
  3. 3What they found
  4. 4Why it might work this way
  5. 5The limits
  6. 6Cold-calling, kindly

Every class has students who answer every question and students who never volunteer. Teachers who want to hear from the second group face a dilemma. They could call on someone whose hand is not raised, which is known as cold-calling. But many teachers hold back, worried that it will embarrass students and make them even less willing to speak. Elise Dallimore, Julie Hertenstein and Marjorie Platt studied what actually happens to students’ willingness and comfort when cold-calling is used a lot.

Why it is worth asking

Class discussion is perhaps the most widely used active learning method, and it depends on students taking part. The worry about students who do not participate is not only that the discussion is thinner. It is that those students may be having a lower-quality learning experience, listening passively while a few others do the thinking out loud.

Cold-calling is one obvious response. The objection to it is emotional, and reasonable: being put on the spot is uncomfortable, and an uncomfortable student may withdraw further. The question is whether that is what happens over time, or whether students adapt.

The study

The researchers compared university classes in which instructors cold-called a lot with classes in which they cold-called little. They looked at two outcomes.

  • Voluntary participation: how many students answered questions voluntarily, and how many voluntary answers each student gave.
  • Comfort: how comfortable students said they felt taking part in class discussions.

The two outcomes answer two different fears. The first is that cold-calling replaces volunteering: students stop raising hands because they know they will be asked anyway. The second is that it makes the classroom feel unsafe. If either fear were right, classes with a lot of cold-calling should show fewer volunteers, lower comfort, or both, and the gap should widen as the term goes on.

Both were followed over the course of the term, so the researchers could see not only whether the two kinds of class differed, but whether the differences grew or shrank.

What they found

Every result pointed the same way.

MeasureClasses with lots of cold-calling
Number of students who volunteered answersSignificantly higher, and rising over the term
Voluntary answers per studentHigher than in low cold-calling classes, and rising over the term
Students’ comfort taking part in discussionIncreased over the term
Dallimore, Hertenstein & Platt (2013), compared with classes with little cold-calling

In classes with little cold-calling, comfort did not change over the term. In classes with a lot, it went up. Students who were regularly called on did not retreat; they became more willing to speak without being asked.

The authors conclude that cold-calling can be done fairly extensively without making students uncomfortable, and that it supports the goal of getting more students to take part in discussion.

Why it might work this way

The study did not test explanations, but the pattern makes sense. When anyone might be asked, everyone has a reason to prepare and to follow the discussion. Answering a few times, and finding that it goes fine, builds the confidence to volunteer. And when being called on is routine rather than a punishment, it loses its sting. In a class where it rarely happens, being singled out is an event; where it happens to everyone, it is just how the class works.

The limits

The classes were in higher education, with adult students. Comparing classes is also not the same as a controlled experiment: classes with more cold-calling may have differed in other ways too. The measures of comfort were students’ own reports. How cold-calling is done surely matters too. A warm, routine question to a student who has had a chance to think is very different from a sharp question designed to catch someone out, and the study does not separate the two.

Cold-calling, kindly

If cold-calling is going to be used, the details of how matter more than the decision itself. The aim is for being asked to feel like an ordinary part of the lesson, something that happens to everyone and has nothing to do with being caught out.

Making it routine and safe

  • Tell the class at the start that you will call on anyone, so it is never a surprise.
  • Give thinking time first, then call on someone. See wait time.
  • Let students talk to a partner before you call on anyone, so they have something to say.
  • Ask for their thinking, not only the answer, and treat partial answers as useful.
  • Spread questions across the whole room, not only the students who look ready.

A quiz in which every student answers on their own device offers a different route to the same goal: everyone responds, every time, and nobody is singled out in front of the class. Many teachers combine the two, using the class results to choose an interesting answer to discuss and then asking a student to explain the reasoning. See polls for quiet students for that approach.

Sources

  1. Dallimore, E. J., Hertenstein, J. H. & Platt, M. B. (2013). Impact of cold-calling on student voluntary participation. Journal of Management Education, 37(3), 305–341.

More from the blog

All posts →