What the research says

Do Leaderboards and Points Help?

Two experiments tested single game elements. A leaderboard got students working on a project far more often; points made people do more, but did not change how much they enjoyed it.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
A small gold trophy on a black base
Photo: Giorgio Trovato, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1A leaderboard on a class project
  2. 2Points, levels and leaderboards, one by one
  3. 3Reading the two together
  4. 4The limits
  5. 5Using a leaderboard well

Points, levels and leaderboards are the most common pieces of gamification, in classrooms and far beyond them. They are also the most argued about. Supporters say they make effort visible and fun; critics say they turn learning into a chase for numbers. Most studies of gamification change many things at once, which makes it impossible to tell which piece did what. Two experiments did something more useful: they tested one element at a time.

A leaderboard on a class project

Richard Landers and Amy Landers ran their study in a university course in which students completed an online project on a wiki. Students were randomly assigned to one of two versions. One had a leaderboard showing how students were doing on the project; the other was identical but without it. Crucially, the leaderboard was not tied to grades. Being at the top earned nothing but the position.

The aim was to test a specific idea about how gamification works. The theory says a game element does not improve learning directly. It changes a behaviour, and the behaviour improves learning. For a leaderboard, the behaviour in question was time on task: how much students worked on the project.

The result was clear. Students with the leaderboard interacted with their project 29.61 more times on average than students without one. And that extra engagement carried through to results: statistical analysis supported the idea that the leaderboard improved academic achievement by way of the extra time students spent on the task. The authors conclude that leaderboards can be used to improve course performance under certain circumstances.

Why would a leaderboard do this? The authors connect it to two lines of research. Leaderboards combine competition with a visible goal, and goal-setting research has long found that a clear, visible goal increases effort. A leaderboard tells each student what doing well looks like, and how far away it is.

Points, levels and leaderboards, one by one

Elisa Mekler, Florian Brühlmann, Alexandre Tuch and Klaus Opwis asked a different question: do these elements change how people feel about a task, not only how much they do?

Participants in an online experiment were asked to tag images, describing what they saw. Some did the task plain; others saw points, levels or a leaderboard alongside it. The researchers measured how many tags people produced, how good the tags were, and how intrinsically motivated people felt: how much they enjoyed the task for its own sake.

MeasuredEffect of points, levels and leaderboards
Number of tagsIncreased
Quality of tagsNo clear change
Intrinsic motivationNo change
Feeling competentNo change
Mekler, Brühlmann, Tuch & Opwis (2017), summary of the findings

In this setting, the game elements worked as extrinsic incentives: they got people to do more, but they did not make the task more enjoyable, and they did not make it less enjoyable either. The authors suggest the lack of effect on motivation is probably due to how the elements were added, as plain counters on an otherwise unchanged task.

Reading the two together

The studies agree more than they first seem to. Both found that game elements increase effort: more interactions with a project, more tags on images. Neither found that the elements alone made people love the task. The Landers study went one step further, and showed that more effort on a worthwhile task translated into better learning.

That suggests a simple rule. A leaderboard or points will mostly make students do more of whatever the task is. If the task is good practice, more of it is good. If the task is busywork, the game elements will produce more busywork. The quality of the activity still matters most.

The limits

Both studies were short compared with a school year, and neither involved children. The image-tagging task was not schoolwork. The leaderboard in the Landers study did not count towards grades, and a leaderboard with real consequences might work differently. And neither study looked closely at the students at the bottom of the board, who may experience it very differently from those at the top.

Using a leaderboard well

For a classroom quiz, a leaderboard is most useful as a way of making effort visible and the game exciting, and least useful when it becomes the same few names every week.

A leaderboard that helps more students

  • Attach it to practice that is worth doing, so the extra effort goes somewhere useful.
  • Keep it out of grades, as in the study.
  • Show only the top few, so lower places are not public.
  • Use teams sometimes, so everyone can be on a winning side.
  • Mix in rounds where improvement, not total score, is what counts.

Whether competition helps or harms has its own body of research, covered in is competition good for learning?, and the wider evidence on game elements is summarised in gamification: what works.

Sources

  1. Landers, R. N. & Landers, A. K. (2014). An empirical test of the theory of gamified learning: The effect of leaderboards on time-on-task and academic performance. Simulation & Gaming, 45(6), 769–785.
  2. Mekler, E. D., Brühlmann, F., Tuch, A. N. & Opwis, K. (2017). Towards understanding the effects of individual gamification elements on intrinsic motivation and performance. Computers in Human Behavior, 71, 525–534.

More from the blog

All posts →