What the research says

What Happened When a Middle School Made Quizzes Routine

Researchers worked inside one American middle school for years, quizzing some lesson content and not the rest. The quizzed material scored higher on real exams, months later.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
A row of salmon-pink school lockers on a tiled wall
Photo: Thomas Park, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1A clever design: quiz some content, not the rest
  2. 2Sixth-grade social studies
  3. 3Eighth-grade science
  4. 4The limits
  5. 5Three quizzes per unit

Most research on quizzing happens with university students in a laboratory. The material is invented, the tests do not count, and the whole thing is over in an afternoon. A team from Washington University in St. Louis wanted to know whether the same effect would show up in an ordinary school, on the real curriculum, in the exams that decided students’ grades. For several years they worked inside a suburban public middle school in the Midwest, alongside a sixth-grade social studies teacher and an eighth-grade science teacher, and published what they found in two papers in 2011.

A clever design: quiz some content, not the rest

Comparing a quizzed class with an unquizzed one invites arguments about which class was stronger. So the researchers compared material instead of students. In each unit, some facts were picked for quizzing and others were not, and the choice was switched between classes. Every student was quizzed on some content and not on the rest, so each student was their own comparison.

The quizzes were short, multiple choice, and answered with clickers. They did not count towards grades. Students saw the right answer after each question. The teacher stepped out of the room for the first quiz, and because each class had a different random set of quizzed items, she could not keep track of which facts were which.

  • A pre-lesson quiz, before the teacher taught the topic.
  • A post-lesson quiz, straight after the lesson.
  • A review quiz about two days later, before the chapter exam.

Sixth-grade social studies

In the first experiment, 142 sixth graders studied units on ancient Egypt, Mesopotamia, India and China. The final measures were the teacher’s own chapter exams, the tests their grades were based on, and the exam at the end of the semester.

ExamQuizzed itemsItems not quizzed
Chapter exams (multiple choice)94%81%
End-of-semester exam79%67%
Roediger, Agarwal, McDaniel & McDermott (2011), Experiment 1

The quizzes themselves show how well the lessons worked. Before the teacher’s lesson, students got 41% of the quiz questions right; straight after it, 93%. The real question was what happens afterwards, over the weeks in which facts that were perfectly clear on the day begin to fade.

The teacher told the researchers that 81% was her usual result, roughly a B. Quizzing lifted those items to 94%. The authors note that if every item had been quizzed, the class average would have gone from a B to an A.

A second experiment answered the obvious objection that quizzes simply show the material again. Some facts were quizzed, some were shown as plain statements to read the same number of times, and some were neither. On the chapter exams, quizzed items scored 91%, read items 83% and untouched items 81%. Seeing the fact again helped a little; having to retrieve it helped much more.

Eighth-grade science

The companion study, led by Mark McDaniel, ran in eighth-grade science classes with 139 students, across units such as genetics and anatomy. The same three-quiz routine produced gains of between 13% and 25% on the unit exams, depending on the experiment. On the quizzes, scores climbed from 58% before each lesson to 83% just after it and 86% on the review.

ExamQuizzed itemsItems not quizzed
Unit exams92%79%
Semester exam79%72%
End-of-year exam68%62%
McDaniel, Agarwal, Huelser, McDermott & Roediger (2011), Experiment 1

The advantage was still there on the end-of-year exam, months after the units had been taught. Two further experiments varied when the quizzing happened. The review quiz before the unit exam did the most good of the three, and adding the earlier quizzes on top of it added only a little more.

The limits

Both studies took place in one school, with one teacher per subject, so the results show what can happen in a real classroom rather than what will happen in every one. The quizzes were multiple choice and so were most of the exams; a third experiment, which used short-answer exams, found a benefit again, which is reassuring but not the same as testing every format. The quizzes also always came with the right answer afterwards, and the studies do not tell us how they would work without it.

Three quizzes per unit

What makes this work persuasive is how ordinary the routine was. No extra lessons, no new materials, a few minutes of clicker questions per topic, and the effect still showed on the tests that counted.

The routine from the two studies

  • Before teaching a topic, ask a few questions on it. Nobody is expected to know the answers yet.
  • After the lesson, ask the same ideas again.
  • A day or two before the test, run a review quiz on the whole unit. This is the one not to skip.
  • Show the right answer after every question.
  • Keep the scores out of the gradebook.

The cost in lesson time was small: a handful of questions at the start and end of a lesson, and one short review session per unit. The teachers kept teaching exactly as they always had. What changed was that students had to pull the material out of memory a few times before the exam asked them to.

The first quiz has its own research behind it: see why a quiz before the lesson helps. And if your students worry about being quizzed so often, the post on quizzes and test anxiety covers what was found when the same team asked them.

Sources

  1. Roediger, H. L., Agarwal, P. K., McDaniel, M. A. & McDermott, K. B. (2011). Test-enhanced learning in the classroom: Long-term improvements from quizzing. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 17(4), 382–395.
  2. McDaniel, M. A., Agarwal, P. K., Huelser, B. J., McDermott, K. B. & Roediger, H. L. (2011). Test-enhanced learning in a middle school science classroom: The effects of quiz frequency and placement. Journal of Educational Psychology, 103(2), 399–414.

More from the blog

All posts →