Does Quiz Practice Work for 10-Year-Olds?
Almost all research on retrieval practice uses university students. Three experiments with 88 fourth graders found it works for children too, whatever their reading level or speed.

In this post
The evidence that practising recall beats re-studying is enormous, but it has a blind spot. Nearly all of it comes from university students, because they are the people psychologists can most easily recruit. Teachers of younger children are entitled to ask whether the same thing holds for a ten-year-old, who reads more slowly, holds less in mind and may find being tested more stressful. Jeffrey Karpicke, Janell Blunt and Megan Smith ran three experiments in an American primary school to find out.
The children
The participants were 88 children from four fourth-grade classes at one public school in Indianapolis, with an average age of 10. The experiments ran in different school terms, and some children took part in more than one. The researchers also measured two things that differ a lot between children of this age: reading comprehension, with a short standard reading test, and processing speed, with a timed task of crossing out matching symbols.
The task
Each experiment used a list of 24 familiar words, each belonging to a clear category: banana is a fruit, football is a sport. The children first heard each word read aloud and then had a minute to study the list silently. Next came about four minutes of practice, in which half the words were practised one way and half the other.
| Restudy | Retrieval practice | |
|---|---|---|
| What the child saw | fruit: banana | fruit: ba___ |
| What the child did | Read the whole word again | Completed the word from memory |
The word-stem format was a deliberate choice for this age group. A blank page asking “write every word you remember” is hard for a ten-year-old, and a child who recalls nothing practises nothing. A category and two letters made recall possible without giving the answer away: the child still had to bring the word back from memory. Both kinds of practice showed the same category cues, so the only difference was whether the child read the word or produced it.
There was no feedback during practice. After a short delay, the children took a final test: writing down every word they could remember in the first two experiments, and picking the studied words out from new ones in the third.
What they found
| Experiment | Final test | Restudied words | Retrieved words |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (40 children) | Free recall | 44% | 55% |
| 2 (40 children) | Free recall | 28% | 42% |
| 3 (42 children) | Recognition | 66% | 77% |
In all three experiments, words the children had practised retrieving were remembered better than words they had re-read. The effects were of medium size and consistent, whether the final test asked children to recall words or only to recognise them. During practice itself, children completed most of the word stems successfully, between 75% and 87% depending on the experiment, so the task was challenging but within reach.
Who benefited
The researchers wanted to know whether retrieval practice favoured some children over others. Children with better reading comprehension did remember more words overall in the first experiment, which is unsurprising. But the advantage of retrieval practice over restudy was about the same across the range of reading ability and processing speed. Slower readers and faster readers, quicker and slower processors, all benefited by a similar amount.
That matters because a common worry about recall practice is that it only suits strong students. Here, at least, it did not.
The limits
The authors themselves describe the findings as preliminary. The material was simple word lists, not lessons, and the final test came minutes after practice, not days or weeks. It was one school and one grade. And the measures of individual differences had a limited range: with more children and a wider spread of abilities, differences might appear. What the study does establish is that the basic effect is not something only adults show.
Retrieval practice with younger classes
The study’s method is itself a model for younger children: short, simple and supported. The children were not asked to recall from a blank page; they had a category and two letters as a cue. That kind of scaffold keeps success high while still requiring real recall.
Recall practice for primary pupils
- Use cues: a category, a first letter, a picture, so recall is possible.
- Keep sessions short: the practice in the study took about four minutes.
- Pitch it so most children succeed on most items.
- Add the correct answer afterwards, which the study did not, to catch the misses.
- Make it a game rather than a test, so the effort feels like play.
Picture questions and simple multiple choice work well with this age group, because they lower the reading load while keeping the recall. For research on how quizzing affects children’s feelings about tests, see quizzes and test anxiety, and for the finding that weaker students may gain the most, quizzes help the students who struggle most.
Sources
- Karpicke, J. D., Blunt, J. R. & Smith, M. A. (2016). Retrieval-based learning: Positive effects of retrieval practice in elementary school children. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, 350.
Try it in Giga Quizzes
Free, in the browser, and nothing for your students to install. These guides show each step on the real screens.
New to Giga Quizzes?
Free live quizzes in the browser. Students join from any phone, with no app.
Make your first quiz →

