What the research says

Quizzes Help the Students Who Struggle Most

Does practice testing only help strong students? A Washington University study found the opposite: with feedback, students with lower working memory gained the most from being quizzed.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
A staircase handrail painted in rainbow colours rising upwards
Photo: Nick Fewings, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1What working memory is
  2. 2The experiment
  3. 3What they found
  4. 4Why feedback matters here
  5. 5The limits
  6. 6Quizzing for the whole class

A reasonable worry about any teaching method is that it helps the students who were already doing well and leaves the rest behind. Quizzing might seem especially at risk. Recalling an answer is harder work than reading it, and students who find school work hard may simply fail to recall, and learn nothing. Pooja Agarwal, Jason Finley, Nathan Rose and Henry Roediger tested this directly, by measuring each student’s working memory and seeing who benefited most from practice tests.

What working memory is

Working memory is the mental workspace that holds information while you use it: keeping a phone number in mind while dialling, or holding the first part of a sentence while reading the rest. People differ in how much it can hold, and working memory capacity is linked to how well students do in school. Students with lower capacity often find complex tasks harder to manage.

In this study, working memory was measured with a standard computer task called operation span, in which people solve simple maths problems while remembering a sequence of letters.

The experiment

The participants were 156 university students, tested in two groups some years apart. They learned obscure general-knowledge facts, such as the city in which the Baseball Hall of Fame is located. Each fact was first shown with its answer. Then, after a short gap, it was either shown again for restudy, or turned into a test question.

Half the students got feedback after each test question, the correct answer, and half did not. Half took the final test 10 minutes later, and half two days later. Without studying, students knew only about 12% of these facts, so almost everything they got right had been learned in the session.

What they found

First, the familiar result. Facts that had been tested were remembered better than facts that had been restudied, both after 10 minutes and after two days.

Final testRestudied factsTested facts
After 10 minutes66%73%
After 2 days42%51%
Agarwal, Finley, Rose & Roediger (2017), all students

Then the question the study was designed to answer: who gained most? At 10 minutes, working memory made no difference. Students of all capacities benefited about equally from testing, with or without feedback.

After two days, with feedback, a clear pattern appeared. The lower a student’s working memory, the bigger their gain from testing over restudying. The correlation was r = −0.42, a moderately strong relationship, and it appeared separately in both groups of students, tested years apart. Without feedback, there was no such pattern.

In the authors’ words, delayed benefits from testing with feedback were significantly greater for students with lower working memory than for students with higher working memory capacity. Retrieval practice with feedback may help to level the playing field.

Why feedback matters here

The role of feedback fits the original worry. Students with lower working memory were less likely to recall facts on the practice test in the first place: working memory correlated with initial recall success. Without feedback, a failed recall leaves nothing behind. With feedback, even a failed attempt is followed by the right answer, and the authors discuss the possibility that having just tried makes that answer easier to absorb. Either way, feedback turns the practice test into a learning event for everyone, including the students who got the most wrong.

That is consistent with other research showing that an unsuccessful attempt to answer, followed by the answer, can lead to better learning than simply studying the answer. The post on pre-testing covers that work.

The limits

The participants were university students, so “lower working memory” here means lower compared with other students at the same university, not a learning difficulty. The material was trivia facts, learned in one session. The groups in each condition were not large, 39 students each, and the authors call for larger samples and more replication. They also note that the work needs to be extended to real classrooms before the conclusion can be relied on there.

Quizzing for the whole class

The practical message is simple. A quiz is not only a tool for the strong. With the right answer shown after each question, it may do the most for the students who find learning hardest.

Making quizzes work for weaker students

  • Always show the correct answer after every question.
  • Treat wrong answers as normal parts of practice, not as failures.
  • Keep scores out of grades, so a weak start does not turn into avoidance.
  • Repeat questions on later days, so students who missed them first time meet them again.
  • Use a pace that gives slower readers time to finish the question.

The study also adds a reason to keep quizzing after students get answers wrong. For the students with the least working memory, the wrong answers followed by the right one may be exactly where most of their learning happens.

Related research on younger children reached a similar conclusion about individual differences: see quiz practice for 10-year-olds.

Sources

  1. Agarwal, P. K., Finley, J. R., Rose, N. S. & Roediger, H. L. (2017). Benefits from retrieval practice are greater for students with lower working memory capacity. Memory, 25(6), 764–771.

More from the blog

All posts →