What the research says

Does Enjoying Maths Lead to Better Marks?

A five-year study of 3,425 German pupils tracked how they felt about maths and how they did. Enjoyment led to better marks, better marks led to enjoyment, and boredom pulled both down.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
Old wooden toy blocks printed with coloured numbers
Photo: Susan Holt Simpson, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1The study
  2. 2What they found
  3. 3Why a loop matters
  4. 4The limits
  5. 5Feeding the good side of the loop

It is easy to see that pupils who are good at maths tend to like it, and pupils who struggle tend to dread it. The harder question is which way the arrow points. Do good marks make pupils enjoy a subject, or does enjoying it make them do better? A team led by Reinhard Pekrun followed thousands of German pupils through five years of secondary school to find out. The answer is both, and the way the two feed each other matters for every teacher.

The study

The data came from a long-running project on maths learning in Germany, known by its German acronym PALMA. It followed 3,425 pupils from grade 5 to grade 9, starting at an average age of 11.7, and the sample was designed to be representative. Every year, the pupils reported how they felt in maths, and every year their achievement was measured in two ways: their end-of-year maths grade and a standardised maths test.

The emotions measured fell into two groups.

Positive emotionsNegative emotions
EnjoymentAnger
PrideAnxiety
Shame
Boredom
Hopelessness
Emotions measured in Pekrun et al. (2017)

Because the same pupils were measured five times, the researchers could ask questions that a single survey cannot. Does a pupil’s enjoyment this year predict their marks next year? Do this year’s marks predict next year’s enjoyment? And they could ask this while holding constant the obvious alternative explanations: the pupil’s gender, intelligence and family background.

What they found

Positive emotions predicted later achievement. Pupils who enjoyed maths and felt proud of their work one year went on to get better grades and test scores the next, beyond what their intelligence and background would predict.

Achievement also predicted later emotions. Pupils who did well one year enjoyed maths more and felt more pride the next.

Negative emotions worked the same way in reverse. Anger, anxiety, shame, boredom and hopelessness predicted lower achievement later, and lower achievement predicted more of those emotions later.

Measuring achievement twice was important. A grade reflects a teacher’s judgement, which might itself be swayed by how keen a pupil seems; a standardised test does not know how the pupil feels. Because the pattern appeared for both grades and test scores, it is unlikely to be just teachers rewarding enthusiasm.

The authors call this a reciprocal effects model, and it held up across all five years, for both grades and test scores, and across the different school tracks of the German system. Emotions and achievement are not one causing the other. They are a loop.

Why a loop matters

A loop can run in either direction. A pupil who does a little better starts to enjoy the subject a little more, works with more energy, does better again. A pupil who has a bad term feels a little more anxious or bored, engages a little less, and slips further. Over five years, small differences can grow.

That has two practical consequences. First, achievement alone is not the only lever. Making a subject more enjoyable, or less boring, is not a distraction from results: the data suggest it feeds into them. Second, success itself is one of the best sources of enjoyment. Pupils who feel they are getting somewhere enjoy the subject more, which means experiences of success, even small ones, are worth designing in.

Boredom deserves a special mention, because it is easy to overlook. It is a quiet emotion; a bored pupil rarely disrupts anything. But in this study it belonged firmly with the negative emotions that predicted lower achievement.

The limits

The study is correlational, even though it follows pupils over time. It shows that emotions predicted later achievement after accounting for several other factors, which is strong evidence of a link, but it is not an experiment in which enjoyment was deliberately changed. Emotions were self-reported. And the pupils were all in one country’s school system, in one subject. The pattern is plausible elsewhere, but it was measured here.

Feeding the good side of the loop

No teacher can make a whole class love maths. But the study suggests that small moments of enjoyment and success, repeated across a year, add up.

Small ways to tip the loop

  • Give every pupil some questions they can get right, so success is a regular experience.
  • Make practice playful sometimes: a game, a team round, a challenge against the clock.
  • Notice progress, not only high marks, so pride is available to everyone.
  • Watch for boredom as closely as for anxiety, and change the pace when it appears.
  • Keep stakes low in practice, so mistakes do not feed shame.

Games are not the only route to enjoyment, and a game that leaves some pupils always losing can feed the wrong side of the loop. Research on whether competition is good for learning and on what motivates students looks at how to keep a classroom game enjoyable for the whole class, not only for the winners.

Sources

  1. Pekrun, R., Lichtenfeld, S., Marsh, H. W., Murayama, K. & Goetz, T. (2017). Achievement emotions and academic performance: Longitudinal models of reciprocal effects. Child Development, 88(5), 1653–1670.

More from the blog

All posts →