What the research says

Does Humour Help Students Learn?

A review of four decades of research found humour helps attention, interest and classroom climate, gives mixed results on learning, and comes with firm rules on what not to joke about.

By the Giga Quizzes team4 min read
A yellow rubber duck wearing sunglasses, floating in a pool
Photo: Rajvir Kaur, Unsplash, Unsplash License, cropped.
In this post
  1. 1What the review covered
  2. 2Where the evidence is strong
  3. 3Where it is mixed
  4. 4Where humour goes wrong
  5. 5The limits
  6. 6Using humour without forcing it

Almost everyone remembers a teacher who made them laugh, and many people credit that teacher with making a subject stick. But is it the humour that helps, or just a good teacher who also happens to be funny? In 2011 John Banas, Norah Dunbar, Dariela Rodriguez and Shr-Jie Liu reviewed forty years of research on humour in educational settings, with a particular focus on why the findings so often disagree. Their review is a useful corrective both to the idea that humour is essential and to the idea that it is a distraction.

What the review covered

The authors started with the basics: how humour is defined, what it does, and the main theories of why it works. They then sorted the kinds of humour teachers use and reviewed the evidence from two directions, what teachers who use humour do, and how students receive it. Most of the research they found was survey work, with a smaller number of laboratory and classroom experiments.

They also listed the types of humour that turn up in teaching:

  • Humour related to the course material, such as a funny example of a concept.
  • Funny stories and humorous comments.
  • Self-disparaging humour, where teachers joke about themselves.
  • Unplanned humour that arises in the moment.
  • Jokes, riddles and puns.
  • Funny props and visuals, such as cartoons.

Where the evidence is strong

Attention and interest. This is the most consistent finding. Humour helps students pay attention and makes a class more interesting.

Classroom climate. Humour builds a sense of cohesion in a group, helps people cope with stress, and can soften criticism so that it is easier to hear.

How students see the teacher. Several studies linked appropriate humour to higher student evaluations, and others linked it to how credible students found their instructor.

Where it is mixed

On learning itself, the review is cautious. The authors write that the conflicting findings on how humour affects information acquisition and recall make it difficult to form unequivocal conclusions. Some studies found better recall of material taught with humour, others found no difference.

One specific use has been studied directly: adding humorous items to exams, usually to reduce anxiety. Across the studies the review summarised, there was little evidence that this improved scores. In most it made no measurable difference, and it did not lower them either.

The review’s practical advice on learning points in one direction: to help students retain material, use humour to illustrate a concept just taught. The logic is simple. A joke that is about the idea gives students another reason to remember the idea; a joke about something else is just a break.

Where humour goes wrong

The review is clearest about the negative cases. Humour related to the material, funny stories and humorous comments are almost always appropriate. Other kinds depend on the context.

Some humour is never appropriate in class: humour that manipulates, mocks or ridicules others, including students’ ignorance or beliefs, and racially or sexually offensive humour. Divisive or disparaging humour damages exactly the group cohesion that good humour builds. Humour used as a tool of control has negative effects. And too much humour, or sarcasm, is linked to lower evaluations and lower credibility.

In short, the same tool that builds a class up can split it apart, depending on who the joke is aimed at.

The authors’ summary of the line is memorable: teachers should use humour that laughs with students rather than at them.

The limits

Much of the research behind the review is survey-based, asking students how they perceive humorous teachers, which shows associations rather than causes. Humour is also hard to study: what is funny varies between people, cultures and ages, and a joke that works in one class falls flat in the next. The review is honest that the field has more open questions than settled answers.

Using humour without forcing it

The practical advice from the review is reassuring. Humour is not required for good teaching, and forced humour backfires. Teachers should use humour that suits their personality and style. Those who do not naturally joke can borrow humour instead: a cartoon, a comic strip, a short clip.

Humour that serves the lesson

  • Make the joke about the concept, so laughing at it means remembering it.
  • Use a funny example right after teaching an idea, to illustrate it.
  • Laugh with the class, never at a student.
  • Keep it occasional: too much humour costs credibility.
  • Borrow humour if inventing it does not come naturally.

Quizzes are a natural home for light humour: a playful wrong answer among the options, a funny picture question, a team name round. Keep the playful option clearly wrong for anyone who knows the material, so it adds a smile without adding confusion, and keep the rest of the question serious. For more on keeping a class engaged without losing the learning, see what motivates students and Friday afternoon quizzes.

Sources

  1. Banas, J. A., Dunbar, N., Rodriguez, D. & Liu, S.-J. (2011). A review of humor in educational settings: Four decades of research. Communication Education, 60(1), 115–144.
  2. Weimer, M. (2013). Humor in the classroom: 40 years of research. Faculty Focus (summary of Banas et al., 2011).

More from the blog

All posts →