Quizzing in Medical and Staff Training
Doctors in training remembered far more six months after a session when they had been quizzed on it. Another trial emailed medical students one question a week, with striking results.

In this post
Medical education has an uncomfortable problem: much of what trainees learn is forgotten long before they need it. A resident may sit through an excellent session on a rare emergency, and meet the emergency itself a year later. Two randomised trials published in the journal Medical Education tested whether quizzing could close that gap, one with doctors in training and one with medical students. Their designs are useful well beyond medicine, for anyone who runs training for adults at work.
Six months after a teaching session
Douglas Larsen, Andrew Butler and Henry Roediger worked with residents in paediatrics and emergency medicine who attended an interactive teaching conference on two topics: status epilepticus, a seizure that will not stop, and myasthenia gravis, a disorder that weakens the muscles.
After the session, the residents were randomly split into two groups. One group took tests on status epilepticus and read a review sheet on myasthenia gravis. The other did the reverse. So every resident was tested on one topic and reviewed the other, and every topic was tested by some residents and reviewed by others.
- The tests were short-answer questions, followed by feedback.
- The review sheets contained exactly the same information as the test answer sheets.
- Testing or reviewing happened straight after the session, and twice more at roughly two-week intervals.
That detail makes the comparison fair. Residents in the review condition saw every fact the tested residents were asked about, written out in full, at the same points in time. The only difference was whether they read the information or tried to produce it first and then saw it.
About six months later, the residents took a final test on both topics. Forty of them completed the study.
| Final test, about six months later | Score |
|---|---|
| Topic the resident had reviewed three times | 26% |
| Topic the resident had been tested on three times | 39% |
Repeated testing produced scores 13 points higher, a large effect (d = 0.91). The low numbers are a reminder of how much is forgotten in six months even by motivated professionals: the review sheets were spaced too, and the topics were taught well, yet most of the content was gone. Testing did not stop forgetting, but it held on to half as much again.
The authors’ conclusion speaks to every training department: testing should be considered for its potential impact on learning, and not only as an assessment device.
One question a week by email
B. Price Kerfoot and his colleagues tried a lighter approach, which they called spaced education. Third-year medical students completed a one-week clinical rotation in urology, including web-based teaching on four core topics. Then, once the rotation was over, they began receiving a short email each week.
Each email contained a single clinical question or case scenario in multiple-choice form. After answering, the student saw the correct answer, a summary of the teaching point and explanations of the answers. Each student was randomly assigned to receive these emails on two of the four topics, so their own scores on the other two served as a comparison.
Students took a validated 28-question test on all four topics before and after the rotation and again at the end of the academic year. Of the 133 students, 95 completed the end-of-year test. Spaced education significantly improved their end-of-year scores. The effect was largest for students who had done their urology rotation longest ago, six to eight months and nine to eleven months earlier, with effect sizes of 1.01 and 0.73. In other words, the emails did most good exactly where forgetting would otherwise have done most damage.
The limits
Both trials were small, at single institutions, and in medicine, where trainees are highly motivated and the stakes are obvious. The residents’ study had only 40 completers. The email trial lost about a quarter of its students before the final test. Neither study measured clinical practice; both measured test scores. But the designs were rigorous, with random assignment and each learner compared with themselves, and both found large effects months later.
Training that lasts
The two studies suggest a simple structure for any training that needs to last: teach once, then test repeatedly over the following weeks and months, with the answer and an explanation each time.
A spaced quiz plan for staff training
- Right after the session: a short quiz on the key points, with feedback.
- Two weeks later: the same ideas again, in new questions.
- Two weeks after that: one more round.
- Then a single question a week or a month, for the rest of the year.
- Always show the correct answer and why, so a wrong answer still teaches.
Short, regular questions fit into a working week far more easily than a refresher course, and the research suggests they do more. The same pattern appears in schools in the middle school quizzing study, and the reasons for the spacing are explained in spacing: three short sessions beat one long one.
Sources
- Larsen, D. P., Butler, A. C. & Roediger, H. L. (2009). Repeated testing improves long-term retention relative to repeated study: A randomised controlled trial. Medical Education, 43(12), 1174–1181.
- Kerfoot, B. P., DeWolf, W. C., Masser, B. A., Church, P. A. & Federman, D. D. (2007). Spaced education improves the retention of clinical knowledge by medical students: A randomised controlled trial. Medical Education, 41(1), 23–31.
Try it in Giga Quizzes
Free, in the browser, and nothing for your students to install. These guides show each step on the real screens.
New to Giga Quizzes?
Free live quizzes in the browser. Students join from any phone, with no app.
Make your first quiz →

